I am not completely agree,but it's nice,thank you!

About S.M.B. "It's a cover album bloated by outsize pretensions,from another is a song cycle lighted by insight and solitude"
. . . i am on the opposite,i disagree,for me:
First: there is an Orchestra,it's not a band with guitar,bass and drums,so it's clear that result it's a sctructural movement of the songs more "full" and "majestic".
But i absolutely find this arrangements NOT pretentious but the opposite: they are simple,innovative,fresh,new,they give way to the beautiful voice (and interpretation of the personality) of Gabriel to express his own way of feeling with this songs.
So,the result is not to listen to songs "mummies",but "new" songs.
Second:i don't understand "solitude". . . . i think S.M.B. is "a point of view" of one of the great and best Artist that we have in this Planet,here in 2010,but there are many moments of Hope,for example whith songs that talks of Love.
Third: i think these songs in a classic review is not easy for anyone,the difference is. . . . Peter Gabriel. He is always able to give that "sense and soul" and innovation in all that he does,would also sing with ten glasses and a fork to make rhythm. . . .
In my opinion,of course,that means that it's an opinion like millions of views in the world. . .